The girls sing

[Sheryl]

My favorite girl tonight was Pia. I've liked her right along and she did a great job tonight.
I also like Lauren. I was thinking she reminded me of Kelly Clarkson and then Randy said something similar.
My third favorite was Karen. Beautiful voice, then Haley. I also liked Naima but the rest can go.
I didn't know the song Ta Tynisa was singing but it sounded like she was completely out of key. I didn't like it at all.
Kendra sounded too screechy.
Rachel had some ok moments but for the most part, I didn't like it.
Lauren didn't do anything for me and Ashton sounded pitchy.
Julie ruined her song. I use to like her but she was horrible tonight.
Thai sounded good on the higher notes but I could barely hear the low notes. Kind of ruined the performance for me.

Not sure who America will pick but I have my top 5.

[Princessrose]

Your top five seem to be mine too.  I thought Pia Toscano was terrific, she gave me goose bumps, I could see her all the way to the top.  I adore Lauren, she's so cute and only what 17?  Ms. Rodriques was my third favorite, that's Karen right?  Have you noticed a lot of this years contestants are of some Hispanic background or Latin/Italian?  I wonder if JLo had any influence in that.  I do like Naima too, but I agree with Randy, no one sang that better then Fantasia did awhile ago.  I love her crazy outfits too.  The blue dress she wore last week with the flower in her hair was so beautiful.  And get a load of that tattoo on her back?  I hope she is in the top five, she has children to support.

[Dizzydeni]

Pia was the best.  I dont know if the girls are strong enough to win but I enjoyed most of them.

[Puchie22]

Pia is my favorite and my second is the Rodriguez girl. Rose, I was thinking the same about the Latinos in it this year, most of them are pretty good. I enjoyed the girl with the curly blond hair, I think she is about 17, she is my third favorite. Didn't care much for the African American girl with the curly hair, I thought she was out of tune and I like Naima but I did not care for the way she sang Stormy Wheather, I can't think of anyone who can sing that song like Lena Horne or the late great Sam Cooke. 
 
Maria

[Puchie22]

 
All my favorites except for Thea got in the first 10. Horrayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy! 
Maria